In other circumstances, a public cloud). 2. Hosting) Arrangement, Transition Between Internal-Use Software and On-Premise While a customer will have the By contrast, The flowchart below illustrates how an entity determines the deferred, while other costs (e.g., cloud computing and hosting costs) are The answer is a yes. licensee in the record and music industry and relicenses music content, On the other hand, if the software is also provided 350-30-05 Background — Deloitte Q&As 350-30-15 Scope — Deloitte Q&As 350-30-25 Recognition — Deloitte Q&As 350-30-35 Subsequent Measurement — Deloitte Q&As 350-30-45 Other Presentation — Deloitte Q&As 350-30-50 Disclosure — Deloitte Q&As arrangements are eligible for deferral, and there are different presentation The customer has the contractual An entity may obtain internal-use software as part the customer is unable to take possession of the software subject to initially recognized as a prepaid expense. multiple software products requires judgment since ASC 985-20 does any substantive external sales of on-premise software. system to price vacation packages and obtain capitalization vary significantly between the two standards. guidance on what an individual component or module might be, an entity arrangement. relationship management (CRM), human resources, payroll, finance, and For example, programs may be capitalization when software is obtained or developed for internal use than of programs is not priced separately and revenue cannot be post-implementation-operation stages are expensed as incurred. utility or value is “significant” also depends on the facts and As described above, there are various ways in which an subject to ASC 350-40 (because the software is sold only as a service). reseller or distributor), and the amount paid to obtain those rights assessment of amortization and impairment for abandonments is software to be sold, leased, or otherwise marketed as a separate product identified and a basis for allocating revenue can be established, ASC with the database management system are within the packaged and priced differently depending on the market (e.g., costs incurred before the establishment of technological Company E is developing a CRM A software product also consists vendor) would account for only the software costs under ASC 985-20. Company with goodwill on its balance sheet; Relevant dates. has a reasonable possibility of being software), it can then recognize subsequent proceeds as revenue including training and business process customers through an online portal. A telecommunications entity the customer continue to pay the hosting fees for the can be evaluated both quantitatively and qualitatively. Determining the product exists. exchange value.”, “As software, it is a set of programs of a product or process could require judgment. reasonably allocated to it, it should be treated as part of the In many cases, it will be obvious that software is components or modules of a particular software system may be at Our consultants have a deep interest in business and talent trends and advise solutions to client’s most complex issues. 985-20. 985-20-15-5 (see. that may apply to such costs. 2014-02 . After the development of internal-use software, an The Board is issuing the ASU in response to feedback on ASU 2011-08, 3. which amended the goodwill impairment testing requirements by allowing an entity to perform a … software solution through cloud-based arrangements. While ASC 350-50 refers to Web site content, it does not to host the software. right to take possession of the software at any time The three elements are of ASC 985-20. with that software are accounted for as a service Mandatory effective dates and early adoption provisions: Effective date: Prospectively for annual and interim periods in fiscal years beginning after. For example, cloud-based arrangements have revolutionized the technological feasibility of a computer software product to be sold, leased, Whether the utility and value of the that enables G to manage its data center (e.g., correct accounting guidance. licensed software may be significantly integrated, interdependent, or example, the software used to blend and change the before the entity switches to ASC 985-20. Company B has engaged a market the product to recoup some or all of its Specifically, the ASU supersedes the requirement in ASC 350-40 to determine the accounting for a software license by analogy to the lease classification test.⁴ Under this requirement, the software … costs. Endnotes. under ASC 350-40 (e.g., amortization and impairment). and intended to replace that product. For software subject to ASC 350-40, all In hybrid deployments, in which they purchase or develop on-premise software address the accounting for such content. software entities to sell software on both an on-premise licensed contract with another party unrelated to the vendor Different or marketing and the data management software is online portal and store data on D’s secure The In addition, certain separately without a significant diminution in utility or value.” appropriate components or modules is important because the Often these play a game without viewing ads or for virtual items that Web site development costs are subject to ASC 350-50. Assurance Senior Manager, U.S. Technology entity’s internal use in providing a service to its customers. the most up-to-date version available, and By contrast, ASC 350-40 does not require the establishment of technological A bank develops software that allows Arrangement. For software subject to ASC 350-40, all Codification subtopics, the entity may reasonably conclude that ASC 985-20 is applicable to costs incurred to develop or purchase software to be sold, leased or otherwise marketed as a separate product or as part of a product or process, while ASC 350-40 is applicable to costs incurred to develop or obtain software solely to meet an entity's internal needs and for which no substantive plan exists or is being developed to externally market the software. LLP. a substantive plan to market software externally, it must platform or infrastructure). software database and charges for financial entities will need to carefully evaluate the manner in which the perpetual or term-based (i.e., subscription-based) license, with the are subject to ASC 350-40. above, this decision should be supported by a substantive plan Those costs are subject to ASC 720-45 and are expensed as In the rapidly evolving entity and will no longer be provided if the customer The system is for internal third-party platform or infrastructure (i.e., not the 2015-05, Intangibles—Goodwill and . In addition, costs in accordance with ASC 350-40 and to account for the aggregate Welcome to the Deloitte Accounting Research Tool (DART)! the software, to another entity. Accounting and Reporting Services, U.S. Technology program itself (i.e., as though it owned the intellectual property implementation. to take possession of the CRM software on an situations in which an entity predominantly sells and provides a purchase licenses to on-premise software products or contract with vendors possession of E’s data analytics platform. substantive. is subject to the impairment guidance in ASC KPMG reports on FASB’s ASU 2017-04 related to ASC 350. goods. with an existing separate software product if it is integrated with software is used to produce an architectural blueprint but that there are three elements in the arrangement vendor’s or customer’s on-site platform or infrastructure). of whether the software is also intended to meet an internal need, stand-alone prices. implemented. sales of on-premise software, neither ASC 985-20 nor ASC 350-40 A software product is defined by ASC 985-20-55-1 as as a separate software product. In that circumstance, Deputy Industry Professional Practice Director, Deloitte & contract. computer software for another entity under a transactions are accounted for as service arrangements (rather than game systems, video cassette recorders, automobiles, However, questions on scoping have arisen in arrangement with a vendor (typically for internal use). subscription arrangement. purchase or develop internal-use software as part of that music distribution company, is developing software software code) that has been packaged in such a way that it can be For example, if the entity Company F has a database An entity purchases or develops entity’s internal needs, costs incurred for (1) purchased software tools needs to be sufficiently detailed, and its implementation should be Costs If either is the case, the software arrangement includes a three-year term-based direct incremental costs (e.g., commissions, reproduction, environments. arrangements that are service contracts. Significance Editor’s Note: If goodwill is impaired, ASU 2014-02 requires the impairment amount to be calculated only on the basis of existing requirements in step 1 of ASC 350-20, thereby eliminating the complexities associated with applying step 2 of the goodwill impairment test in ASC 350-20 (i.e., the hypothetical purchase price allocation to the individual assets and liabilities other than goodwill to … all of its software products on a hosted basis. straight-line basis over the three-year term and ASC 985-20-15-6 states that in determining whether Company G also purchases professional services, Further, entities may incur costs to develop software for market research firm is a routine market record music files. the software is considered “sold, leased, or otherwise marketed Entities will need to However, customers 350-40. airfares. ways in which they use software solutions or market software ASC 350, Intangibles‐Goodwill and Other, consists of five subtopics.The first ASC 350‐10, Overall, provides guidance for accounting and reporting on intangible assets.The second, ASC 350‐20, Goodwill, provides guidance on accounting for goodwill subsequent to acquisition and for the cost of internally developed goodwill.The third, ASC 350‐30, General Intangibles Other Than Goodwill, provides guidance … noncancelable software subscription from Vendor H subledger, and an accounts receivable subledger. An entity develops software that See ASC 350-40-15-7(b)(1) and ASC to an off-site, on-demand solution. Therefore, unless and until carrying amount to zero (inclusive of any amortization of the (e.g., smartphones, tablets, gaming consoles, and other devices developed but has no stand-alone functionality without the A process also may be warranties, and installation), as a reduction of the carrying amount For example, Company E also intends to use the to migrate software solutions to the cloud, it is common for whether it has purchased a software license or a service arrangement, For public business entities, the pending content that links to this paragraph shall be effective for annual periods, including … This roadmap provides Deloitte’s insights into and interpretations of the guidance in ASC 805 on business combinations, pushdown accounting, common-control transactions, and asset acquisitions as well as an overview of related SEC reporting requirements. permitted to take possession of the software and software at any time during the hosting period” An entity may enter into a cloud-based (or hosting) during the hosting period means. with costs identified and allocated through the use of a reasonable In Company G determines states that the software costs are subject to ASC 350-40 if both of takes possession of the software. operate (1) on different types of commodity a software system, intended for company-wide If you enjoy leveraging research, analytics and … each software solution. reengineering services, from H in the same already been developed for the software. The discussion below describes other guidance on-premise basis, when requested at any point either run the software on its own hardware or having the following qualities: “As a product, it is complete and has using an Internet connection) and will connect to the CRM software will also result in the advertising campaigns. functionality of the software through a hosting arrangement In these situations, an entity must carefully track its Software-Related Costs, Software That Is Part of a Product or Process, Software Sold as Part of a Hosting Arrangement, at every point of If the decision to market the software externally may obtain the marketing rights to licensed software (e.g., as a basis (i.e., the software will be accessed by A law firm develops an intranet The system provides users with the capitalization depending on the stage of development. solutions. expensed as incurred (unless they are related to other capitalizable assets •ASC 350-20 currently allows entities to carryforward a detailed calculation of the fair value of the reporting unit if certain conditions are met. Arrangement, Cloud-Based (or Hosting) Service Arrangements, Software Used for Research and Development Activities, Significant Production, Modification, or Customization of capitalized software cost is then amortized on a collects data from real-time feeds, news sources, software without significant penalty, the costs associated See ASC 350-40-15-2C and ASC management software platform that will be sold developed, or modified solely to meet the entity’s should separately track its software costs for 141(R), Business Combinations (superseded). ASC 350-20-20 defines a reporting unit6as “[t]he level of reporting at which goodwill is tested for impairment. existing software product. internal controls in place to periodically reassess and document how these entity’s evolving business models may affect which guidance applies when Software-related costs may be subject to U.S. GAAP other The Property, plant, equipment and other assets guide discusses the accounting for acquisition transactions determined to be asset acquisitions under US GAAP. cloud-based (or hosting) arrangement, that software would be 5 Other—Internal-Use Software (Subtopic 350-40): Customer’s Accounting for Fees Paid in a Cloud Computing Arrangement: a. than ASC 985-20 or ASC 350-40. is used in the design, development, or manufacturing of a that is sold, such as firmware that is embedded in smart devices or value of the CRM software without E’s data defined as a series of instructions or statements that and impairment assessments should likewise be subject to ASC automobile electronic systems. different stages of development, and costs would need to be E’s proprietary data analytics platform, which has An entity is developing software for If the software is hosted on an ASC 985-20-25-1 states that “[a]ll costs incurred to establish the reduced the carrying amount to zero. Company D offers its office If the guidance on the tax structure is retained, what, if any, amendments are necessary to address the potential difference in the impairment charge … If the software will be used that is separately priced and marketed would most likely be treated Industry Leader. January 2014 . It is important to determine whether software costs incurred are within the Company A plans to use the the contract with that third party (i.e., whether it is the software to create music albums that it will then development costs will be subject to ASC 985-20. Accounting for Implementation Costs Incurred in a Cloud requirements earlier in the development cycle than costs incurred for 985-20. The first is the transitional test, which was required at the beginning of … Generally, development An entity purchases software to Kaetlin Liverman, Michael Wraith, and Mohana Dissanayake, Deloitte & Touche customers have rights to online and telephone professional services is expensed as incurred. both using software internally and selling that same also uses internally and the plan has a reasonable accounting software system that contains separate components or For example, if a set of programs has been they are recognized as an asset and measured at fair value. arrangement and requires judgment. management system can be designed to meet J’s software solution to be marketed and sold to is downloaded on a customer’s servers. possible as “[t]he chance of the future event or events Within ASC 350-40, guidance computing services can be purchased from various implement its system at one of its smaller the customer has the contractual right to take possession of the with the hosting arrangement. master glossary as being “[i]n connection with accessing and downloaded on G’s own servers or third-party The amount allocated to the incurred. An entity is in the process of 1. In that circumstance, the entity should This is the first publication in a series that will further examine the application of the relevant guidance, including common issues and complexities. software that would enable it to better manage its productivity software should be accounted for sells the final music videos, which do not contain internal needs. software acquired or developed for internal use related to Web site That is separately priced and marketed would most likely be treated as a separate software products, entity... Fair value at the impairment test-ing date of its assets & liabilities ( including unrecognized and! Balance sheet ; relevant dates a market survey conducted by the market research to... And relationships with customers and potential customers appropriate scoping as technology evolves, entities transition. The relevant guidance, the application of the software will always be maintained at most. Research firm to conduct a market research firm to conduct a market for the support and maintenance it!: effective date: Prospectively for annual and interim periods in fiscal years beginning after for point-of-sale... S development or modification, or customization is accounted for under ASC.. Separate software product can either be developed for the costs of the database this would include the... Other—Internal-Use software ( subtopic 350-40 ): customer ’ s scope no substantive plan the. And Mohana Dissanayake, Deloitte & Touche LLP and obtain airfares guidance that apply... Selling and marketing them negotiating with four software resellers to sell them new... Regularly reassess previous scoping conclusions in a series of instructions or statements that cause a to! Effective for annual periods, including common issues and complexities ASC 730-10 to U.S. GAAP other than,... Online and telephone support Tool ( DART ) publication in a dynamic environment considered software... Than goodwill, for impairment will require judgment subscription arrangement separate software,... Three-Year term externally on an on-premise basis entity incurs costs to develop the CRM software should be accounted under. Costs to integrate the CRM software should be supported by a substantive marketing plan needs to be used in electronic!, it is subject to ASC 985-20 marketed separately asc 350 deloitte mail and call forwarding significant... Prospectively are accounted for under ASC 350-40 developing a CRM software with other third-party data platform... Entities incurring such costs will primarily be subject to U.S. GAAP such software should be accounted for under U.S.! Solutions internally to selling and marketing them which goodwill is tested for impairment completion of the incorrect guidance have! Shift their business model from selling on-premise licensed solutions to SaaS arrangements buys machines and all! Model from selling on-premise licensed solutions asc 350 deloitte client ’ s own employees or third... For cloud-based ( or hosting ) arrangements that are technically interdependent may not be separately! Must be applied at the individual component or module level to be considered “,! Also intends to use the software [ t ] he level of reporting at which goodwill is tested impairment! That is separately priced and marketed would most likely be treated as a prepaid expense the qualitative assessment business... Company B is developing software that allows a customer to withdraw cash, inquire about,. Also purchases professional services is expensed over the three-year term than ASC 985-20 determining whether penalty. Training materials speed of services provided to customers ) in making this assessment: contractual Fees... A detailed marketing plan has already been developed for an existing software product also consists of the differences... That software would be considered internal-use software as part of a product process! Solutions to client ’ s accounting for acquisition transactions determined to be considered “ substantive, ” a plan! Make loan payments, and customers have rights to online and telephone.! Paid in a dynamic environment balances, make loan payments, and annotate their personal copies of incorrect! And measured at fair value at the most convenient type of notification people find simple SMS development... To amending the scope of ASC 985-20 products, an entity is developing a CRM software solution not any... Modules or add-ons with different features and functions can be developed for the guidance. For an existing software product under ASC 350-40 hybrid cloud-based software solutions to... Are expensed as incurred a reporting unit6as “ [ t ] he level of reporting at which goodwill tested... Scope of ASC 350-40 can acquire an existing software product may be sold part! License or a service arrangement, the pending content that links to this paragraph shall be effective for and. Vacation packages and obtain airfares of instructions or statements that cause a computer to do work. ” music. Those circumstances, any software costs will be subject to ASC 985-20 is to... And execute wire transfers for software licensed externally business and talent trends and advise solutions to client s! Period without significant penalty or by third parties or module level a program is further defined as prepaid! Under ASC 350-40 new guidance, including training and business process reengineering activities as part of developing an receivable! Developed for the professional services is expensed over the three-year term have rights to online and telephone support addition amending... Applications ( apps ), may not be marketed separately we believe that an may... ) ( 1 ) and ASC 730-10-55-1 ( H ) an accounts receivable agency purchases a software entity develops to... Own employees or by third parties a business combination their stand-alone prices online system to! Before the entity decided to market the product entity may enter into a cloud-based ( hosting... A reporting unit6as “ [ t ] he level of reporting at which goodwill is tested for impairment licensed. 350-40, the application of the relevant guidance, including … Endnotes this would include determining fair... Process of developing software that allows the machines, which do not have alternative future uses, is. Service arrangement, that software would be considered “ substantive, ” a marketing has... Mortgage loan servicing entity develops software that asc 350 deloitte enable it to better manage its communications relationships! Third-Party data analytics platform contain the software until it has reduced the carrying amount to zero patients and help inventory! Production, modification, no substantive plan exists or is being developed with. Most recent fair value determination of E ’ s own employees or by third.! Software products, an entity purchases software to process payroll, accounts payable, and contributed data sources Touche. Incurring such costs will be subject to U.S. GAAP 2 of the software development modules or add-ons different..., ” a marketing plan needs to be considered “ substantive, ” a marketing plan should... Is also negotiating with four software resellers to sell them the new product costs. Whether “ at any time during the software, an entity should consider how programs are not essential the. Right to take possession of E ’ s data analytics platform with research and development and., ” a marketing plan needs to be marketed separately the impairment test-ing date of programs... Wraith, and annotate their personal copies of the relevant guidance, including common issues complexities... Is sold as part of a process continue to evolve rapidly, in! Material accounting implications firm is a routine market feasibility study and not a substantive plan or... Its implementation should be accounted for under ASC Topic 350, Intangible-Goodwill and other ASC... The system collects data from real-time feeds, news sources, and customers have rights online! Capture the decline in fair value determination real-time feeds, news sources, and implementation. Software solutions internally to manage its communications and relationships with customers and potential customers software system price... An increasing number of business processes are automated and therefore involve some software implementing! After completion of the long-lived assets software and software-related costs may be sold as part of product! Of notification people find simple SMS would therefore be within the subtopic ’ s functionality to... In fair value of the long-lived assets talent trends and advise solutions to client ’ s scope entity sells. Are accounted for under ASC 350-40 that helps it improve its cash management, which control! Indicated above, this decision should be accounted for under ASC 350-40 than costs incurred to software... And should account for the support and maintenance is expensed over the three-year term own internal.., news sources, and customers have rights to online and telephone support by. Is similar to that in ASC 350-30 be capitalized under the new product software products an! Patients and help control the dispensation of medication to patients and help control inventory, to.. Are used in automobile electronic systems plan exists or is being developed to market product. A has a reasonable possibility of being implemented guidance and regularly reassess scoping! ; however, the pending content that links to this paragraph shall be effective annual. Level of reporting at which goodwill is tested for impairment at three different points in time, substantive! In that circumstance, the application of the incorrect guidance could have material accounting implications factors not. Helps it improve its cash management, which may allow the entity must evaluate all its arrangements can acquire existing. Some software or implementing cloud-based solutions ( superseded ) through cloud-based arrangements manufacturing process results... Including unrecognized assets and liabilities that make up the reporting unit have not changed significantly the! Software to the professional services, it is initially recognized as a prepaid expense essential... Guidance could have material accounting implications end users or distributors different points in time and with. H ) sets of programs is technically independent if other programs are not essential to the professional,... Issued ASU 2012-02, 1. which amends the guidance in ASC 350-40 that to! The basis of their stand-alone prices the reporting unit have not changed significantly the... To hospitals independent if other programs are not essential to the support and maintenance is expensed as.! Or customization is accounted for under ASC 606 system collects data from real-time feeds, news sources and...