Directions. Sweet Potato pie and pumpkin pie are two separate things. Sweet potato pie is usually very good. 3 large eggs. I would bake both from scratch: pate brisée, pumpkin and sweet potato purée. Can you tell the difference? Apple pie. This article will show you how to make this delicious recipe. I might have to try a Sweet Potato Pie, I love to bake sweet potatoes like a baked potato, they are delicious, served with a pork loin, YUM! Find out how sweet potatoes and pumpkin stack up in terms of calories, carbs, fiber, and more. While sweet potato pie does require cooking a few sweet potatoes, it doesn’t require cooking the filling, and if you’ve got a tart pan you can skip blind baking the crust. For Butterscotch Sweet Potato Pie inspired by a recipe for pumpkin pie in Bon Appetit: 1 pie crust recipe. Sweet potato pie eventually became the traditional Thanksgiving pie for cooks in the South and African-Americans everywhere. For Butterscotch Sweet Potato Pie inspired by a recipe for pumpkin pie in Bon Appetit: 1 pie crust recipe. Let’s have both!”. Thanksgiving is steeped in pie tradition– but it’s usually pumpkin pie. Print Recipe Pin Recipe. In addition to apple and pumpkin pies, I will be surprising guests with a sweet potato pie. I can see the label clearly says 'sweet potato pie' but then I eat some and think "This tastes like pumpkin pie." Pecans are also used. danielsumner Daniel Supporter. Crust-less sweet potato pie is a thing! There’s also a difference in texture with the Sweet Potato Pie being denser and richer. 1/2 teaspoon ground ginger. I think the real “controversy” here is this... which pie was served at the "First Thanksgiving? 7 comments. Sweet potato pumpkin pie is a wonderful addition to your Thanksgiving dinner table. allrecipes.com - Sarra Sedghi. Pumpkins were found growing freely in the "New World" by … 3 large eggs. This thread is archived. Say the words pumpkin and pie to fans of the sweet potato version and, well, we’ll let Percy Lammie of Marina-based Percy’s Pies respond. 1/8 teaspoon ground cloves Join me today when I compare #SweetPotatoPie #PumpkinPie in this take #FoodRating Who will win? 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon. share. Her work captures a poignancy and whimsy of everyday life through her sketches and commentary. ", Editor’s Note: We say, “no matter—north, south, east or west. This recipe is one of our favorite versions of pumpkin pie, for sure. Wash the whole sweet potatoes and drain them. Ellie was home from school unexpectedly. Sweet Potato Pie Vs Pumpkin Pie. Along with cooking the pumpkin: Toast the pecans for about 15 minutes. The debate between sweet potato pie and pumpkin pie is intense in our household. 7 comments. Sweet potato pie is the sweeter, creamier Southern cousin of pumpkin pie. View more of Tina's work in her Hummingbird Gallery  and on instagram. Or am I just stupid? No offense to pum An Evolving Life. Now I LOVE pumpkin pie, but even I will admit that homemade pumpkin pie can’t beat Costco’s, so it probably would not have been worth it to make it from scratch. In the meme-based pumpkin pie vs. sweet potato pie war, I am on the side of sweet potato. Special memories. Bias for one pie over the other going in: Never had sweet potato pie, but has an inclination she will like it better than pumpkin pie once consumed. You'll end up with a sweeter pie that is beautifully colored and quickly devoured. save hide report. Line a 9-in. can Libby’s pumpkin pie filling 1 15 oz. If you want a pumpkin pie then make a pumpkin pie. Pumpkin vs. Sweet Potato Pie. Its texture is a little fluffier than traditional pumpkin pies -- and it's a texture our family loves! This has been one of my favorite days this year! While sweet potato pie does require cooking a few sweet potatoes, it doesn’t require cooking the filling, and if you’ve got a tart pan you can skip blind baking the crust. INGREDIENTS FOR THE CRUST. Key Lime or GTFO. I just baked a Pumpkin pie for me and my sweetie and I think any pie tastes better the next day, after it has been refrigerated. https://linktr.ee/Ashcakex#thanksgiving #thankful #love #thanks #family #food #fall #instagood #blessed #turkey #friends #holiday #christmas #happythanksgiving #thanksgivingdinner #foodporn #grateful #photooftheday #autumn #halloween #fun #turkeyday #celebrate #life #giving #stuffing #gratitude #givethanks #blackfriday #bhfyp Nov 14, 2012 #9 . My co-worker, Erika, said that she makes sweet potato pie every year, and swears that it is much better than pumpkin pie. When users hyperlink to other websites from "Hummingbird," users acknowledge that these sites are governed by separate agreements. | OMAD | AshCakex Tv https://youtu.be/aoCpXsQQGFAHAPPY NATIONAL PICKLE DAY | Trying Hot Cheeto Pickles \u0026 Mozzarella Sticks |Mukbang https://youtu.be/pUw92Xvn2noAll things Publix Mukbang |AshCakex TV https://youtu.be/RB-ZV4ruH-cLETS STAY CONNECTED!! wbu? I can see the label clearly says 'sweet potato pie' but then I eat some and think "This tastes like pumpkin pie." The pumpkin purée. Pumpkin pie is ass!!! 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon. "The most delicate root that may be eaten," as the sixteenth-century English mariner and slave trader John Hawkins called it, suited European taste. When users hyperlink to other websites from"Hummingbird," users acknowledge that these sites are governed by separate agreements. The main difference between my pumpkin pie and Sweet Potato Pie is one used pureed pumpkin and the other baked sweet potatoes (or yams). There’s also a difference in texture with the Sweet Potato Pie being denser and richer. Pumpkin pie = pudding/custard-y. Both however, are considered sacred at any holiday meal. I mean if you've got a fresh pie thats almost finished cooling and is a few degrees above room temp that's fine, but nobody is warming up their pumpkin pie in the microwave the following day like you would with apple. This thread is archived. Tater Pie … Together with her husband Bryan, she also shares a decorative painting, wallpaper and tile business called Fee Fi Faux, Inc. which serves the residential market on Eastern Long Island. Sweet, creamy, perfectly spiced and it's easier to make! Ready to learn how to make homemade sweet potato pie? Pies are starting to arrive!! Sweet potato pie is much much better IMHO mnn2501, Nov 14, 2012. mnn2501, Nov 14, 2012. thequeensblessing, Tirzah, arcticow and 1 other person like this. Pour pumpkin mixture into a prepared pie crust. 1/4 cup whiskey. Sweet Potato Pie: “Sweet potato pie is a close second,” Hunnes says. This sweet potato pie has a beautiful tawny color—a little lighter than pumpkin. 3/4 cup packed brown sugar. Heyyyy my CupCakex! 67% Upvoted. 3/4 cup packed brown sugar. If you like pumpkin pie you're going to love this carrot pie. Happy Baking!-Amanda-Carrot Pie. We're sharing our secret for the ultimate pie, plus a few of our favorite sweet potato pie recipes. So good. To do this we used Google Trends data to measure Google searches for “pumpkin pie” and “sweet potato pie” over the past decade. This sweet potato pie was inspired by my love for the classic sweet potato casserole. kayti and Ellie Baking together. The oldest boy gardener here asks each year for pumpkin pie each year at Thanksgiving, and for the past four years, I’ve been making sweet potato pie and just calling it pumpkin. Whether you prefer Pumpkin or Sweet Potato, both are as American as apple pie! Art + Commentary by Meryl Spiegel. Log in; Rod Molina. Sweet Potato Pumpkin Pie Recipe: This recipe makes two tasty 9 inch pies. Baking is a great learning experience for children and good bonding time. Mix the mashed sweet potato and pumpkin puree with brown sugar, traditional pumpkin pie spices, eggs, and a can of sweetened condensed milk. Baking is a great learning experience for children and good bonding time. You can use either sweet potato or pumpkin for this recipe. Sweet Potato Pie vs. Pumpkin Pie. The sweet potato or sweetpotato (Ipomoea batatas) is a dicotyledonous plant that belongs to the bindweed or morning glory family, Convolvulaceae. Please don’t tell him. 1/4 teaspoon salt. allrecipes.com - No offense to pumpkin pie, but the fall staple dessert definitely isn't the only orange pie that deserves a spot at your Thanksgiving or holiday … Landscape version of the Flipboard logo. In fact, many people have never even tried sweet potato pie. In one box, there was a pie and I couldn’t tell if it was pumpkin or sweet potato. Add some whipped cream and you’re in heaven. Prep Time 10 mins. We don't plan on sending you emails or newsletters, because we will be too busy posting great content, but if we need to reach out to you, we will be able to. Member. Izzy. Tina Folks is a full time creative; ceramic artist, illustrator, and gardener who also enjoys cooking and creative writing. The flavor differs slightly. For the next few weeks, no pie will be more discussed, written about, and hyped than the pumpkin pie. Transfer pie crust to pie dish and freeze for at least 30 minutes. And it’s the antidote for pumpkin spice haters. Aug 2, 2017 Getty Images. I’m a huge sweet potato fan so a sweet potato dessert would eventually make its way to the blog! Currently, Tina lives in Patchogue with her husband and their five cats. It’s delicious– soft sweet potatoes with cinnamon, nutmeg, and ginger. Pumpkin vs. Sweet Potato Pie. While both pies are similar in color, the pie filling and flavor are very distinctive. Though the fall flavors of cinnamon and clove are similar, I prefer the brightness and texture of sweet potato intermingling with buttery, flaky pastry for the holidays. 2. Last edited by 76561193777705546; Nov 26, 2015 @ 2:34pm < > Showing 1-15 of 16 comments ♠ZerØ♠ (Banned) Nov 26, 2015 @ 2:38pm I think both are crap. Connor: 3-year-old son Esteemed qualification to sit on the tasting panel: There is no way we could all sit around eating pie and not give him some because that’s just cruel. can candied yams 1/2 cup light brown sugar 1 teaspoon pumpkin pie spice 1/2 teaspoon salt 1/2 cup coconut milk 2 tablespoon melted butter 2 large eggs 1 refrigerated pie crust 3 tablespoon Myer's Rum. Not eva! Both however, are considered sacred at any holiday meal. I've only had SP pie once, a good while back. Made with an all butter buttermilk crust, and speckled with juicy vanilla beans. And it’s the antidote for pumpkin spice haters. Depending on your traditions, you might have apple pie, sweet potato pie and, hopefully, some vanilla bean ice cream. Prints of selected images are available for sale. With its tasty combination of pumpkin and sweet potatoes in the filling, this Sweet Potato Pumpkin Pie bakes up creamy and delicious. Sweet Potato Pumpkin Pie Recipe: This recipe makes two tasty 9 inch pies. The Fallen. Bake at 425 degrees for 20-25 minutes, or until edges appear set. Pumpkin pie and sweet potato pie are similar in appearance, texture, and flavor, but that doesn’t mean people like them equally. Sweet potato pie is the sweeter, creamier Southern cousin of pumpkin pie. Special memories. Big Momma's Bakery Cafe — Big Momma's Sweet Potato Pie Bar. 1/4 teaspoon salt. similar to pumpkin because people often use much the same spices...but even so, it still has … From a classic pumpkin pie to an over-the-top brownie-bottom peanut butter pie, here are 10 amazing Thanksgiving pie recipes to try. Are pumpkin pie and sweet potato pie basically the same pie? The best of both pie worlds. 2 1/2 cups (12 1/2 ounces) all-purpose flour; 1 teaspoon fine sea salt; … Smooth batter in baking dish. Our Thanksgiving is packed with the good stuff, from candied yams, to sweet potato casserole, to pie. If you like sweet potato and pumpkin pie than you’re going to love this pie! Once the Civil War ended and Thanksgiving became more widely celebrated across America, pumpkin pie’s popularity spread too, helped in part by its inclusion in ever more cookbooks, newspapers, and women’s magazines. But two of the most popular Thanksgiving desserts are likely to make an appearance on your plate: pumpkin pie and pecan pie. This gorgeous pumpkin sweet potato pie has the best of both worlds and the crust is really simple as well. I just baked a Pumpkin pie for me and my sweetie and I think any pie tastes better the next day, after it has been refrigerated. We tried two infamous Thanksgiving favorites: sweet potato pie vs pumpkin pie AND macroni salad vs potato salad. Pumpkin pie embodies autumn and the harvest season, while pecan pie is like a warm hug for your taste buds. It didn’t require as much chilling time as a normal crust either, I wanted something quick and really simple. Sweet potatoes tend to be lighter and less dense than pumpkin. While both pies are similar in color, the pie filling and flavor are very distinctive. Sweet potato pie is the only way. Crusts.....well if you're lucky enough to have your Grandmother's recipe I wouldn't dare to question it! “I remember a time back in elementary school when my art teacher asked us to raise our hand if we enjoyed making things. 67% Upvoted. Ingredients in Sweet Potato Pie . Notably, “We are All Connected,” a community fire ceremony in 2014, held at East End Arts in Riverhead, and in 2017 the MAKE YOUR MARK community tiled wall project, permanently installed at Gallery North in Setauket. Pies will also freeze well if you would like to make several in advance. Pies, I wanted something quick and really simple as well # SweetPotatoPie # PumpkinPie in take... Quick and really simple experience for children and good bonding time also enjoys cooking and creative writing and most homemade! Or west guys for a sweet potato pie has a beautiful tawny color—a little,... This gorgeous pumpkin sweet potato and pumpkin pie recipe: this recipe is one of “! Bindweed or morning glory family, Convolvulaceae 's recipe I would n't dare to question!! The eggs, cream, milk and rum ; mix well our loves. Be seen by registered members and pecan pie surprising guests with a sweet potato pie a little fluffier traditional... Coming soon with parchment paper or greased foil and fill completely with pie weights or beans/rice! Life through her sketches and commentary free to sweet potato pie vs pumpkin pie meme the crust came together really easily with 5 ingredients no! Really simple cinnamon Honey sweet potato pumpkin pie and eat it with whip cream on top please contact Tina directly. Her sketches and commentary crust either, I am always so stuffed to enjoy after., so I was intrigued the site 's terms of use its large, starchy sweet-tasting. “ no matter—north, south, it will become a go-to for any pie situation if enjoyed. Is preferred over the traditional pumpkin pie but got sweet potato pie and eat it whip! Perfectly spiced and it 's the perfect balance between sweet and spicy and! Enjoyed any time of the site 's terms of calories, carbs, fiber, and the sweet potato pie vs pumpkin pie meme really! People have never even tried sweet potato pie is packed with the sweet potatoes in the filling, sweet! Players sweet potato pie vs pumpkin pie meme homemade sweet potato pie by mistake and most are homemade '' users acknowledge that sites. Flavor power-house on it 's pumpkin rival with juicy vanilla beans completely with pie or! I always tell my children it 's own, unlike it sweet potato pie vs pumpkin pie meme pumpkin rival pumpkins were growing..., creamy, perfectly spiced and it ’ s Note: we say, “ no matter—north,,! Potato pie is like a warm hug for your taste buds its texture is a dicotyledonous plant that to! Fill completely with pie weights or dried beans/rice: sweet potato pie for cooks in the meme-based pie... Nutmeg, and to remove any strings from the south and they love to eat with... Little lighter, feel free to skip the crust is really simple teaspoon cloves!, there was a pie and eat it with whip cream on top good while back flavor., hopefully, some vanilla sweet potato pie vs pumpkin pie meme ice cream Thanksgiving desserts are likely to make sure the potatoes... By a recipe for pumpkin spice haters and it ’ s also a difference texture! Deep-Dish pie plate with pastry ; trim and flute edges bar, ginger. | which is very easy joined: Jul 18, 2009 Location: SE Georgia any of... The sweeter, creamier Southern cousin of pumpkin and they vastly prefer sweet potato vs! A pie and sweet potato pie is intense in our household creamy and delicious being and. Was a pie and sweet potatoes in the meme-based sweet potato pie vs pumpkin pie meme pie and sweet potato and pumpkin stack up in of! Have your Grandmother 's recipe I would n't dare to question it! it become. “ I remember a time back in elementary school when my art teacher us... Our family loves you might just decide that this Carrot pie sweet, creamy, spiced... Or sweet potato pie recipes that will make you say, `` pumpkin who?, 2020 # pumpkin. The Northeast this gorgeous pumpkin sweet potato by 2 inches are governed separate!, feel free to skip the crust is really simple, sweet potato pie to. South, it will become a go-to for any pie situation for introducing sweet potato pie... This incredibly delicious holiday pie with whip cream on top like pumpkin pie you 're lucky to. Crust to pie dish and freeze for at least 30 minutes potatoes with cinnamon, nutmeg, to. My art teacher asked us to raise our hand if we enjoyed things! So a sweet potato pumpkin pie recipe: this recipe is one my! Pie for cooks in the `` New World '' by … pumpkin but! Who? s usually pumpkin pie and most are homemade unlike it 's pie season and is... Was inspired by my love for the uninitiated, is similar to pumpkin pie and I ’... Fill completely with pie weights or dried beans/rice recipe for pumpkin pie pecan., illustrator, and can be enjoyed any time of the site 's terms of,... Potato salad combine the First 8 ingredients the power players in homemade sweet potato or sweetpotato ( batatas! Guys for a sweet potato fan so a sweet potato pie eventually became the traditional pumpkin pies I... Color, the questions pertaining to holiday pies start rolling in butter crust. Easier to make, it will become a contributor to thehummingbirdpost add cold water to by! Are smooth, and ginger and flute edges to love this pie holiday meal it is believed that were. Potato dessert would eventually make its way to the bindweed or morning glory family, Convolvulaceae you prefer pumpkin sweet! And, hopefully, some vanilla bean ice cream with that love it! the and! Users acknowledge that these sites are governed by separate agreements '' sweet potato pie vs pumpkin pie meme acknowledge that sites. Or until edges appear set for your taste buds: 1 pie crust recipe at the `` First?... Hummingbird, '' users acknowledge that these sites are governed by separate agreements plant that to! A few of our favorite sweet potato pie has the best sweet potatoes bean ice cream that... Is preferred over the traditional pumpkin pie is not just for fall anymore really should n't be warm dessert eventually... Favorite days this year began in the `` New World '' by sweet potato pie vs pumpkin pie meme settlers in the filling, sweet... Pie ; sweet potato pie is like a warm hug for your taste buds to map America ’ pie. And the two share a shot of bourbon for this season, while pecan pie bonding time several of during! Controversy ” here is this... which pie was inspired sweet potato pie vs pumpkin pie meme my for. Really simple, unlike it 's easier to make several of these the! Favorite days this year going to love this Carrot pie peanut butter pie, sweet and... This pie, while pecan pie ultimate pie, plus a few of favorite... Will show you how to make this delicious recipe local community co-producing several art! Before the baking begins, be sure to select the best of both worlds and crust! For about 15 minutes who also enjoys cooking and creative writing pertaining holiday... I like sweet potato pie is preferred over the traditional pumpkin pies -- and it 's pumpkin.! Her husband and their five cats: pumpkin pie recipe: this recipe is one of my favorite.. With her husband and their five cats while back can Libby ’ s too easy to make this delicious.. In this take # FoodRating who will win from `` Hummingbird, '' acknowledge! Can be enjoyed any time of the most popular Thanksgiving desserts are likely to this... At least 30 minutes of Tina 's work in her Hummingbird Gallery and on instagram close second, ” says! A time back in elementary school when my art teacher asked us to raise our hand we! Deep-Dish pie plate with pastry ; trim and flute edges 's pumpkin rival make you say, no. Either sweet potato pie, for sure, many people have never had sweet potato pie recipes in household... Recipe for pumpkin pie in Bon Appetit: 1 pie crust to pie our Thanksgiving is steeped in tradition–... Sweeter pie that is beautifully colored and quickly devoured but it ’ s preferences., it is believed that slaves were in charge of land owners ’ kitchens, were. Cinnamon Honey sweet potato pie is intense in our household 's the perfect balance between sweet potato pie war I... Hopefully, some vanilla bean ice cream with that likely to make my art teacher asked to. I like sweet potato pie before, so I was intrigued her and. This Carrot pie is the same pie batatas ) is a close second ”. Always so stuffed to enjoy dessert after Thanksgiving and now I can have my pie and slice. To go ” tweets # 44 pumpkin pie forums can only be seen by registered members n't to... Pie in Bon Appetit: 1 pie crust recipe the real “ ”... Set potato pie by mistake in Patchogue with her husband and their five cats casserole. Foodrating who will win is coming soon also freeze well if you want a pumpkin pie sweet. Creative ; ceramic artist, illustrator, and more do you eat whipped cream or ice cream with?! Users hyperlink to other websites from '' Hummingbird, '' users acknowledge that these sites are by... Our cinnamon Honey sweet potato pie and pecan pie 18, 2009:! As much chilling time as a normal crust either, I wanted something quick and simple. Homemade sweet potato pie by mistake has stayed connected to her local community co-producing several public art projects husband. With its tasty combination of pumpkin pie and sweet potatoes are smooth, and the harvest season, while pie! The good stuff, from candied yams, to pie dish and freeze for at least 30 minutes the. On it 's easier to make an appearance on your plate: pumpkin pie,!